BF Goodrich Advantage Control vs Michelin CrossClimate 2 – Which is Better?
BF Goodrich Advantage Control vs Michelin CrossClimate 2 — which tire should you buy? If you’re choosing between these two popular all-season options, this guide cuts through the noise and gives clear, useful answers. We compare real performance—dry and wet grip, snow handling, ride comfort, tread life, and value—so you can pick the tire that fits your driving and budget.
Whether you drive mostly in mild weather and want a dependable, budget-friendly tire, or you face rain and occasional snow and prefer a premium, do-everything option, this article breaks down the pros and cons in plain language. Read on to learn which tire is best for your car, how each performs in everyday conditions, and the simple reason one may be the smarter choice for your needs.
Quick Comparison – BF Goodrich Advantage Control vs Michelin CrossClimate 2
Here’s a snapshot of how the two tires compare:
Tires Overview: BF Goodrich Advantage Control vs Michelin CrossClimate 2
Michelin CrossClimate 2
The Michelin CrossClimate 2 is a tire built for drivers who want one tire that works well all year long. Whether you drive a sedan, a crossover, or a small SUV, this tire is designed to handle a variety of conditions without needing seasonal changes.
How It Works
The tire has a directional tread pattern with V-shaped grooves. Think of it like channels that help water and snow move away from the tire. This design gives you better grip in rain, light snow, and wet roads, making driving safer and more predictable.
Performance
- Dry roads: Provides strong stopping power and stable handling.
- Snow: Excellent grip for light to moderate snow thanks to its 3PMSF certification, which means it meets safety standards for winter driving.
- Longevity: UTQG rating (~640 B A) shows it has good tread life and durability.
Pros
- Handles dry, wet, and snowy conditions well
- Comfortable and quiet ride
- Suitable for sedans, crossovers, and small SUVs
- Long-lasting tread and reliable performance
Cons
- Slightly higher price compared to some all-season tires
- May have a small impact on fuel economy due to all-weather design
The Michelin CrossClimate 2 is like a reliable all-weather companion. It keeps you safe and comfortable whether it’s sunny, rainy, or snowy, making it a great choice for drivers who want one tire that does it all.
BF Goodrich Advantage Control
The BF Goodrich Advantage Control is designed for drivers who want a reliable, everyday tire that performs well in most conditions. It’s a great choice for sedans, crossovers, and smaller SUVs, especially in areas with mild weather.
How It Works
This tire uses special grooves and tread patterns to provide good grip on dry and wet roads. It’s built to give a smooth, stable ride, keeping your car comfortable and controlled during everyday driving.
Performance
- Dry roads: Offers responsive handling and strong braking.
- Wet roads: Performs well in rain, with grooves that help prevent slipping and hydroplaning.
- Snow: Suitable for light snow, but it’s not designed for heavy winter conditions.
- Longevity: Comes with a long mileage warranty, so it lasts a long time with normal use.
Pros
- Comfortable and quiet ride
- Reliable traction on dry and wet roads
- Long-lasting tread and good warranty coverage
- Affordable compared to premium all-season tires
Cons
- Not ideal for heavy snow or icy conditions
- Lacks some advanced all-weather features found in premium tires
The BF Goodrich Advantage Control is like a dependable everyday tire. It keeps your car safe and comfortable for daily driving, especially if you live in mild climates and want a solid tire that won’t break the bank.
Dry Performance and Handling: BF Goodrich Advantage Control vs Michelin CrossClimate 2
In dry conditions—the typical scenario for many drivers—the difference between these two tires becomes more nuanced.
BF Goodrich Advantage Control
In dry handling the Advantage Control offers a responsive feel and stable handling. According to its manufacturer spec sheet, its design includes a “g-Wedge Sidewall Stabilizer” and advanced all-season compounds that aim to deliver control over a variety of conditions. BFGoodrich Tires Owners on forums say:
“The handling is beyond expectations and they are quiet and smooth.”
That suggests it gives more driver-engaged feedback than some other touring all-seasons.
Michelin CrossClimate 2
Michelin’s CrossClimate 2 also performs strongly on dry pavement. Manufacturer data shows that in size 235/55R18 on a 2020 RAV4, stopping distance from 60 mph was 113 ft—better than many competing tires. Long-term reviewers noted handling “maybe improved a smidge over stock OEM tires” in their test vehicle.
That’s impressive for an all-season tire with such broad weather capability.
If you drive primarily in dry or mild conditions, both tires perform well. Advantage Control edges toward a more value-oriented reliable touring feel, while CrossClimate 2 offers a slightly more premium feel with high confidence even in varied conditions. If your dry weather driving dominates and budget is a concern, Advantage Control might be the more logical choice.
Wet Traction and Hydroplaning Resistance: BF Goodrich Advantage Control vs Michelin CrossClimate 2
Wet road performance is critical—especially in places with heavy rain or monsoon seasons.
BF Goodrich Advantage Control
The Advantage Control uses Aqua-Flume™ technology—curvilinear grooves designed to evacuate water from under the contact patch. On the manufacturer’s site it claims it can “stop 8 feet shorter in the wet than leading competitive tires.” Independent ratings (Tire Rack) list the Advantage Control as a strong performer in the Grand Touring All-Season category, with drivers consistently praising its wet weather grip.
On forums a user wrote:
“Excellent on the highway and did very well in the rain…”
This suggests that for everyday wet-road commuting, this tire is reliable.
Michelin CrossClimate 2
The CrossClimate 2 excels in wet conditions. Manufacturer specs claim very strong performance even when worn: e.g., up to 56 ft shorter stopping distance in wet tests versus four leading competitive tires. Independent reviews say:
“Our wet road test revealed that the CrossClimate 2 is the best all-season tire in rainy conditions. It beats every competitor in every metric.”
Drivers on Reddit also note strong wet handling:
“They handle great and have been smooth for me … little noise.”
However, one caution:
“The MPG can be a deal breaker though …” (with the CrossClimate2)
So while the wet performance is excellent, there may be trade-offs (fuel economy, cost).
If you face frequent heavy rain, standing water, or hydroplaning risk, the CrossClimate 2 has an edge. If your wet conditions are moderate and your budget tighter, the Advantage Control still delivers very solid wet performance for its class.
Winter and Snow Performance: BF Goodrich Advantage Control vs Michelin CrossClimate 2
Even if you live in a mild climate, occasional snow or ice can make a difference. If you live in a colder region or travel to snowy terrain, this section is critical.
BF Goodrich Advantage Control
The Advantage Control is an all-season tire but does not carry the 3 Peak Mountain Snowflake (3PMSF) symbol in many sizes, which means it’s not certified for severe snow service. In other words, it’s designed for year-round use in moderate conditions, not heavy snow or icy mountain roads.
Forum users in colder climates caution that while it’s “adequate for light snow”, it may not match dedicated winter or all-weather tires. That means if winter driving is a significant part of your usage, this might be a limitation.
Michelin CrossClimate 2
Michelin built the CrossClimate 2 to bridge that gap. It does carry the 3 PMSF symbol—meaning it meets a recognized standard for severe snow service. In long-term testing after >30,000 miles, reviewers found the tire handled snow, rain and cold with no meaningful compromises:
“… this tire succeeds in its mission brilliantly.”
One user said:
“Excellent in snow, ice, rain, etc… I would recommend this tire to anyone who wants these features and wants to leave a set of tires on their car year round.”
That’s high praise.
If you live in a region that sees snow, frequent freezing temperatures or ice, the CrossClimate 2 is the smarter all-season choice. If winters are very mild (e.g., little snow/ice), the Advantage Control may suffice, and you might save cost.
Ride Comfort and Road Noise: BF Goodrich Advantage Control vs Michelin CrossClimate 2
How a tire rides—its comfort, quietness and feel—can affect daily driving satisfaction more than raw specs.
BF Goodrich Advantage Control
The manufacturer promotes the Advantage Control as “overall quieter than a leading competitor”. User reviews support that perception:
“So far I am greatly impressed with these tires, … immediately noticed much better ride quality and less tire noise.”
So for drivers valuing comfort and quiet highway cruising, this tire is a strong contender.
Michelin CrossClimate 2
With the CrossClimate 2, long-term reviewers found the ride very quiet, with no significant noise increase even after tens of thousands of miles:
“The CrossClimate 2 tires have no added tire noise after two years. They are like a normal all-season tire with regard to sound levels.”
Even though this tire offers snow capability and high performance, its comfort credentials remain high.
Both deliver high ride comfort. If you’re extremely sensitive to noise and want the quietest possible ride in everyday conditions, Advantage Control may be slightly more cost-friendly. If you want excellent comfort AND high all-weather performance, CrossClimate 2 offers “premium” feel.
Read More: Bridgestone WeatherPeak vs Michelin CrossClimate 2
Tread Life, Warranty, and Value for Money: BF Goodrich Advantage Control vs Michelin CrossClimate 2
How long your tire lasts, and the value it gives per mile driven, is a key buying factor.
BF Goodrich Advantage Control
The Advantage Control boasts a 75,000-mile limited mileage warranty in many sizes. Independent sources show very positive owner feedback on durability. For many drivers, this offers strong value in the premium all-season segment.
Michelin CrossClimate 2
Michelin’s longevity claims are impressive: in one test after ~31,000 miles the CrossClimate 2 measured about 6.5 mm tread remaining, and projected life of ~75,000 miles or more at the same rate. Another test cited nearly 77,590 miles projected life in size 225/60R18 (vs Bridgestone rival ~41k miles) in a controlled test.
That kind of longevity offsets its premium cost.
Value Comparison
- Advantage Control: Lower purchase cost, strong manufacturer warranty, excellent user reviews for ride/noise; slightly less capability in winter/snow.
- CrossClimate 2: Higher purchase cost, but premium performance, premium comfort, excellent longevity and winter capability.
So value depends on how you drive and where you live.
Read More: Pirelli Scorpion WeatherActive vs Michelin CrossClimate 2
Ideal Tire for Your Driving Style
If You’re Considering the BF Goodrich Advantage Control
Picture this: you’re someone who drives mostly around town or on smooth highways. You live in a place where winters are mild—maybe you get a little rain, but not much snow. You just want a tire that keeps your car stable, comfortable, and dependable for your everyday commute.
That’s where the BF Goodrich Advantage Control fits in. It’s a practical, budget-friendly tire that focuses on giving you a smooth and steady ride day after day.
Think of it like a reliable pair of sneakers—comfortable, durable, and ready for whatever the day brings. It’s not flashy, but it does its job well. You’ll notice the quiet ride, good grip on dry roads, and long tread life that keeps your tires lasting for years.
If your driving is mostly city streets, weekend trips, or daily commuting in fair weather, the Advantage Control is a smart, value-packed choice that you can trust.
If You’re Considering the Michelin CrossClimate 2
Now imagine you live somewhere with unpredictable weather. One day it’s sunny, the next it’s pouring rain—or maybe even snowing. You want a tire that can handle it all without making you worry every time the temperature drops.
That’s the Michelin CrossClimate 2. It’s like having a tire that’s ready for anything the road throws at you—rain, slush, or dry pavement.
Drivers who choose this tire often care about comfort and quietness. They like the idea of one tire for all seasons, instead of switching between summer and winter sets. It gives peace of mind knowing your car will grip the road whether you’re climbing a wet hill or driving home through light snow.
If you want something premium and dependable, and you don’t mind paying a bit more for extra safety and comfort, the CrossClimate 2 is an excellent fit. It’s ideal for drivers who face frequent rain, colder climates, or long highway drives and want a tire that feels smooth and secure all year long.
Expert Opinions and Real User Feedback
When it comes to choosing between the BF Goodrich Advantage Control and the Michelin CrossClimate 2, it helps to hear from those who’ve tested them in real life.
Experts often praise the Michelin CrossClimate 2 for its all-weather grip and smooth, quiet ride. Reviewers from trusted sources like Tire Rack and Consumer Reports note how confidently it handles wet and snowy roads, calling it one of the best all-season tires for changing weather.
On the other hand, the BF Goodrich Advantage Control earns high marks for its solid traction, long tread life, and great value. Drivers appreciate its balance of comfort and performance without the premium price tag. Many describe it as a dependable everyday tire that feels stable and secure, especially on dry and wet roads.
In short, experts and drivers agree:
- Choose BF Goodrich Advantage Control for everyday reliability and affordability.
- Choose Michelin CrossClimate 2 if you want premium comfort and top performance in any weather.
Which Tire Should You Buy BF Goodrich Advantage Control or Michelin CrossClimate 2?
Both the BF Goodrich Advantage Control and the Michelin CrossClimate 2 are excellent choices in their respective categories. The key is matching the tire to your driving environment, priorities and budget.
- If you’re driving mostly in good to moderate climates, seeking comfort, decent all-season reliability and value—go with the Advantage Control.
- If you want premium capability, including snow/ice resilience, strong all-weather performance, and top-tier ride comfort—and you’re willing to pay more—choose the CrossClimate 2.
In the BF Goodrich Advantage Control vs Michelin CrossClimate 2 comparison, the “winner” isn’t universal—it depends on your conditions. But whichever you choose, you’ll be equipping your car with a top-tier all-season tire.
FAQ
Which tire wears out faster?
Real-world data suggests the CrossClimate 2 has excellent tread life and projected mileage in tests. Advantage Control also offers strong warranty coverage. If your driving involves aggressive use or heavy braking, the premium cost of CrossClimate 2 may pay off in longevity.
Can I use CrossClimate 2 in heavy snow?
Yes—the CrossClimate 2 carries the 3 PMSF symbol, meaning it’s rated for severe snow service. Advantage Control lacks that in many sizes, so it may not deliver optimal snow/ice performance in very cold or mountainous conditions.
Will the CrossClimate 2 hurt my fuel economy?
Some users reported a small drop in MPG when switching to CrossClimate 2. If fuel economy is a top concern, this is something to keep in mind.
Are both available for SUVs / larger vehicles?
Yes. Both brands offer SUV/XL load versions of these tires. Always check your vehicle’s size, load rating and speed rating when selecting. For example, the Advantage Control HT (for light trucks/SUVs) is another variant.
Which value is better overall?
If you drive mostly under “normal” conditions and want comfort + value, Advantage Control may give you more “bang for your buck.” But if you drive in tougher conditions and value longest lifespan + top performance, CrossClimate 2 may justify its premium.
Conclusion
Choosing tires is about matching your vehicle + driving style + environment. In this comparison of BF Goodrich Advantage Control vs Michelin CrossClimate 2, you’ve seen how each excels in different areas: comfort, wet traction, snow handling, longevity, value.
Take a moment to reflect:
- Where do you drive most often (climate, roads, condition)?
- What’s your budget for tires and how many miles do you expect to drive them?
- How important are noise, comfort and winter/ice traction to you?
Answering those will steer you toward the right choice. And whichever you pick, replacing older or worn tires with either of these models will be a meaningful upgrade. Safe driving—and enjoy your next set of tires.
